MayorSlay.com ABOUT | NEWS | BLOG | CONTACT US
Mini PollsBig PictureField TripSt. Louis Traffic

Mini Poll: Is Everyone A Critic?


Current Totals:

In general, how willing are you to try new things?


I am an early adopter: I will try new things before anyone else does:
 32%
I am cautiously adaptable: I will try new things, eventually:
 57%
I am a classic: I will wait and see what stands the test of time:
 11%

 

Before you try something new, how important is it to you that the thing/experience has gotten good recommendations from people whose opinions you trust?


Very important:
 18%
Sort of important:
 56%
Not very important:
 20%
Irrelevant:
 5%

 

For which of the following sorts of "new things" do you most rely on other people's opinions or recommendations before making your own choice?


Movies:
 13%
TV shows:
 4%
Dating:
 2%
Foods/restaurants:
 29%
Electronics:
 39%
Books:
 4%
Clothes/fashion:
 2%
Music:
 2%
Art:
 0%
Theater:
 4%

 

Which of the following types of reviews do you find most useful?


Books:


reader: 75%
|
writer: 25%

 

Movies:


viewer: 75%
|
filmmaker: 25%

 

Restaurant:


diner: 78%
|
chef: 22%

 

Music:


listener: 72%
|
musician: 28%

 

Which of the following best describes the most important element in your selection of a new movie to go see?


Interesting preview in a theater:
 16%
Interesting commercial on TV:
 7%
Top-rated on percentage-rating websites, like rottentomatoes.com:
 3%
Favorite stars are in it:
 8%
Like the genre:
 25%
Good reviews by movie critics I trust:
 24%
Location of the theater:
 3%
Price of the ticket:
 2%
Spousal (or spousal equivalent or kid) pressure:
 3%
I go to whatever movie that is not sold out when I want to go:
 1%
I never go see new movies:
 7%

 

Have you ever walked out of a theater because the movie was so bad?


Yes, I frequently do that:
 1%
Yes, but only rarely:
 54%
No:
 39%
No, but I have walked out of the theater because the audience was so bad/loud/popcorn stealing/handsy:
 6%

 

Which of the following local movie reviewers would you most trust to pick a movie you are going to like?


Harper Barnes (St. Louis Beacon):
 11%
JC Corcoran (K-HITS--at time of publication):
 3%
Tom Kavanaugh (St. Louis Review):
 2%
Cate Marquis (The Current):
 4%
Sandra Olmstead (St. Louis GFCA):
 0%
Joe Pollock (critic emeritus):
 11%
Mark Reardon (KMOX):
 5%
Kevin Steincross (FOX 2):
 3%
Pete Timmermann (PLAYBACK:stl):
 1%
Joe Williams (Post-Dispatch):
 15%
I wouldn't really trust any of them:
 45%

 

How do you decide to try a new restaurant?


I look at the menu online:
 25%
I look at recent restaurant reviews signed by local food critics:
 38%
I look at anonymous online reviews by purported customers:
 10%
I go wherever my spouse/significant other/kids/friends say to go:
 19%
I look at the ads in glossy magazines:
 2%
I always go to the same restaurants:
 5%

 

Which of the following are you most likely to do when you next go out for a big evening in the City?


I will probably eat somewhere I've never eaten before:
 46%
I will probably eat somewhere I've eaten many times before:
 45%
"Next" could be "never," given my finances:
 10%

 

Which of the following local foodies' opinions would you most trust to select a new restaurant for you?


Joe Bonwich (Post-Dispatch):
 30%
Russ Carr (Sauce Magazine):
 17%
Ian Froeb (Riverfront Times):
 17%
George Mahe (St. Louis Magazine):
 1%
Rose Martelli (St. Louis Magazine):
 5%
Cristy Miller (Alive Magazine):
 4%
Michael Renner (Sauce Magazine):
 17%
S.C. Truckey (Sauce Magazine):
 8%

 

Which of the following best describes how you usually find new music?


I hear new songs by listening to the radio:
 50%
I plug in my likes and dislikes to a music-matching website, like Pandora.com:
 14%
I convince my friends to make me mixed tapes:
 7%
I read music magazines like Spin or Rolling Stone:
 5%
I just buy the new albums of bands I already like:
 10%
I use the song recommendations on iTunes:
 3%
I rarely listen to music; do not have a music collection:
 11%

 

Which of the following are you more likely to do?


Purchase an album of a band I don't know much about:
 18%
Purchase an album of new songs or re-released hits of a band I already like:
 82%

 

Which local music reviewer would you most trust to do the iPod playlist for a three-hour car trip?


Thomas Crone (ThomasCrone.com):
 22%
Matt Fernandes (Post-Dispatch):
 12%
Keegan Hamilton (Riverfront Times):
 16%
Kevin C. Johnson (Post-Dispatch):
 22%
Bill Streeter (Lo-Fi Saint Louis):
 15%
Annie Zaleski (Riverfront Times):
 14%

 

From which of the following sources are you most likely to get the next book you read?


From the library:
 20%
Borrowed from a friend or family member:
 7%
Purchased at a thrift store, yard sale, or charity event:
 4%
Ordered from a website:
 17%
Downloaded from Amazon to my Kindle:
 8%
From a bookstore, like one of the Left Bank Books stores in St. Louis:
 34%
Somewhere else:
 10%

 

Why did you choose the book you are reading right now?


It was on a Best Seller list:
 6%
It was on a class syllabus:
 2%
It was recommended by bookstore/library staff members:
 6%
It got good anonymous reviews on an online site:
 3%
It got good reviews from local or national book critics:
 14%
I judged the book by its cover:
 19%
I wrote the book:
 3%
It was recommended by a friend or family member:
 31%
I am not currently reading a book:
 1%

 

Which local book reviewer would you most trust to help you choose the only book you'll have on your vacation?


Amy Woods Butler:
 2%
Steve Geigerich:
 6%
Ann Haubrich:
 3%
Repps Hudson:
 3%
Harry Levins:
 13%
Aimee Levitt:
 6%
Myron Marty:
 3%
Nick Otten:
 1%
Dale Singer:
 9%
Amanda St. Amand:
 0%
I'd pick the Left Bank Books staff suggestion with the best handwriting:
 54%

 

Note: Due to rounding, results for some questions may not total 100%.


1341
Make a Contribution
Mini-Poll
Big Picture
Field Trip
St. Louis Traffic
PAID FOR BY SLAY FOR MAYOR
Contact Us | Privacy Policy